Friday, February 2, 2007

Banning Trans Fats: Out Of The Frying Pan, Into The Fire

Copyright (c) 2007 Debbie Fontana

Studies have shown that trans fats reduce our levels of HDL
(the good cholesterol) and increase our levels of LDL (the
bad cholesterol). All of which may be bad for your heart.

So cities across the US have either already banned trans
fats from their restaurants or are considering doing so.
All in the name of protecting the public health.

Also, many food companies are reformulating their foods to
eliminate trans fats. But then they have to. Otherwise,
they'll be portrayed as the bad guys trying to make a buck
off the poor, unsuspecting public by poisoning us with
their unhealthy foods.

The campaign to raise public awareness of the dangers of
trans fats has led many consumers to believe that a ban
will be healthy for them. So there are many people who are
all for it.

**But The Hype Has Just Begun**

In fact, a recent study actually tried to link trans fats
to infertility.

Even nutritionist Marion Nestle, PhD, MPH, a professor at
New York University, expressed skepticism about that
conclusion in an article recently published on WebMD.

So are city governments justified in banning trans fats
from our foods? Or are these local governments making a
mistake because of all the anti-trans fat hype?

Regardless of how you feel about the government legislating
what we eat, here's the problem.

Trans fats are being replaced in many foods by a new type
of fat called interesterified fats.

But according to the results of a study published in the
journal, Nutrition and Metabolism, interesterified fats may
be even more dangerous for us than trans fats.

You see, interesterified fats also lower our levels of HDL
(the good cholesterol). Just like trans fats. So there's
still a heart health issue.

**But Now There's A New Health Risk**

Interesterified fats were found to significantly increase
blood sugar and depress insulin. Which may increase your
risk for diabetes. Or cause potential problems for you if
you already have diabetes.

If you remember, trans fats replaced saturated fats years
ago because saturated fats were supposed to be unhealthy.
At the time, trans fats were believed to be healthier.

So much for that conclusion. But it gets worse.

These new interesterified fats were found to increase blood
sugar by 20% more than good old saturated fats.

That was in a mere four weeks. Imagine what would happen
over a longer period of time.

**Out Of The Frying Pan, Into The Fire**

It seems like every time the food police insist on changing
the type of fats found in our food, they introduce new and
potentially more dangerous health risks for us.

If you're concerned about this new diabetes risk, you can
check the ingredient list of your foods if it's available.
Interesterified fats are labelled as "fully hydrogenated
oil."

But maybe it's time to consider another course. Maybe we
shouldn't be reformulating our foods after every study. And
we certainly shouldn't be banning foods unless we're sure
the alternatives are safer.

Most importantly, maybe it's time for the food police to
get off their high horses and quit telling the rest of us
how to eat. They don't exactly have a good track record.

**Should We Stop The Trans Fat Bans Before It's Too Late?**

I'm not arguing that trans fats are healthy. But I think
it's a foolish mistake to reformulate all of our foods
until more studies have been done. We need reasonable proof
that we've found a safer alternative.

If you're concerned about the health risks from these new
fats, you may want to get in touch with your local
legislators. And stop the ban on trans fats until we know
for sure that we aren't jumping out of the frying pan and
into the fire.


----------------------------------------------------
Debbie Fontana is a full-time author and business owner who
specializes in writing about health, weight loss, and
nutrition. She invites you to visit her blog and post your
comments about the ban on trans fats. Do you agree?
Disagree? Do you think the food police are helping or
hurting us? Please post your comments at
http://www.ILoveToCheatDiet.com/blog/trans-fat-hysteria

No comments: